Lot of hopes on this one, this will be the make it or break it update for me. If this doesn't make Odyssey decently playable I won't buy it.
If you won't try for yourself, how will you know if it's decently playable or not? I consider Odyssey decently playable but I guess your preference on who's word you're taking may be based on..?
My advice to you (and anyone else), if you're sincere about wanting Odyssey but wanting it to be 'decently playable' first; buy it, give it a fair shot, if it's not playable by your standards, then refund it. It's really that simple. There's literally no downside to it and you will know for sure based on your own preference.
For those who aren't too fussed by the onfoot stuff and are on the fence, all the extra available outposts (and there's a lot of them!) are quite a large bonus to the ship based gameplay of Elite, the new lighting is great IMO and the light atmospheric planets are nice too, and being able to get out of your ship/SRV and meet other players on foot is
way better than bumping shields in a ship or srv...