Not too fussed personally about Odyssey owners not getting Horizons 4.0, but it does seem like an own-goal
- Any group of commanders with Horizons can now play 4.0 together, but as soon as one decides 'I want to go full monty with Odyssey' they now cannot play with their friends except by everyone downgrading to 3.8? I foresee a lot of refunds and accompanying bad reviews
- And if that one commando can persuade all their friends to upgrade? Again I think some will resent being forced to upgrade just to play together - more bad reviews.
- If that brave Odyssey commando had been allowed to run EDH4.0 with their Horizons commander buddies then they'd have been constantly reminding the others about upgrading, and they could have done it one at a time instead of needing to go in lockstep. Pester power at its strongest. And a positive experience = positive reviews.
Not everyone is going to have a Bruce on their shoulder whispering
'it's a free trial for the upgraded codebase, you have to play in old school 3.8 if everyone wants to play together', they'll just think it's a weird restriction.
The only way I can see this making sense is if fdev think 4.0 is a minor upgrade on 3.8, and - I hate to be the one to break this to you ... it's a lot better. People won't want to go back. People won't be happy if you force them to play in 3.8 just to see each other ... (and that's not even to mention that they then miss out on the new 4.0 exclusive content)
Anyway, thank you for coming to my TED talk, the brochures are at the back - max one per group please.