Logging is cheating, its as simple as that. I really cant understand why folks fly in Open if they cant accept the risk.
Ultimately you are exactly correct. Too bad you didn't start this thread.
Unfortunately it started off with two strikes against it:
1) SDC (of all groups!!) waving a in-game morality flag. Can't get more ridiculous then that.
2) Super-scientific CL sample size of 5 in 5 months. Almost as good. This proves...what?
CL is "cheating" and it is wrong. But who cares? That subset of player types (PvP'er) who do absolutely nothing to help themselves on this forum. That's not to say a few are not rational but after making a valid point (unlike here) their PvP fellows have to jump on and ruin the original point with inane arguments and examples.
I don't PvP - I can't - my internet connection doesn't allow it and occasionally struggles with PG but I support the PvP quest in that Open is Open. If you don't want to be ganked, engage in PvP combat, or have your T7 blown up by an Engineered FdL, then why the hell are you in Open? So you fly in Open and then CL when the going gets tough?
I would be very curious who is actually CLogging. The trader minding his own business or the PvP'er who bit off more then he could chew. I have my suspicions about who and what your typical CL'er is.