My first two stars didn't even need a fleet carrier, just flew to them in my Phantom, no need even for Jumponium, surprised they were missed in earlier passes. Anyway that was out as far as I need to go this run, about 10kly, so have turned around to get the other two on the way back to the bubble, shouldn't be more than a day or two and this area will be cleared for now!
Glorious HIPs - 3306
- Thread starter Jackie Silver
- Start date
-
- Tags
- exploration
Turns out HD 110184 is 501 ly from HIP 60415, so inaccessible for now. I suppose I should have checked using https://spansh.co.uk/nearest ahead of time, but I did get some first footfalls on the way and got to see Rackham's Peak, so it wasn't for naught.
Many thanks for that. I thought I had carefully checked the coordinates of all these stars.
But the ones for HD 110184 were out by 51ly. So apologies for that.
That is a big error, normally they are within +/- 2 ly on each axis, so the maximum error should be 3.5 ly.
So when the search program finds anything within 10ly of 500ly, I check it more carefully.
But this is such a big error it obviously didn't get checked.
I have no explanation as to why there is such a big error. It doesnt look like a typo, getting the wrong sign or misreading the direction of the axes, they are the usually things.
Anyway, good luck on your journey to HD 155803. I just checked the coordinates of that star again and this time got (-1433,3317,17757) which is out by 13ly in the z-axis. Fortunately this error is in the direction of the closest star, so the separation should now be less than 409ly. It would be interesting to see if your estimate of the coordinates matches mine.
I have previously suspected, and am now convinced, that these coordinates move around until someone visits them.
edit: Turns out I do have an explanation.
I really did have the correct coordinates in the unreachable stars reference file. As I had checked those very carefully.
But - the nearest star finder program needs the star names by slice, so there is an intermediate step to add the slice numbers for that process.
That is what I forgot to run - so the coordinates were the old ones. And not just HD 110184, although HD 155803 should be ok.
Will have to run the whole suite again.
Will do that tomorrow when the new version of spansh data is available, and includes HD 76952 which I'll get to this evening.
Last edited:
HIP 78413 scanned. A pretty typical system.
HD 151328 scanned. Only stars.
I'm off to HD 155803. I should arrive in a day.
HD 151328 scanned. Only stars.
I'm off to HD 155803. I should arrive in a day.
Ok, done and dusted, a bit disappointing really, 2 systems with just stars, one system with 1 planet and one with 25 bodies. Nonetheless, that's section 11 and 12 done
Because of the small errors we found yesterday, which meant that some stars were actually unreachable, I realised that those errors could also work the other way round.
That stars with dubious coordinates and which are just over the 500ly limit could actually be closer and therefore reachable.
Many of these coordinates were produced by various Commanders some time ago when accuracy wasn't as critical as now.
This will take some to time to check out, and given the timing of your posts, it seems the Spansh data won't be up-to-date until Sunday at the earliest.
So don't expect any confirmation of completion for the time being !
My last star was HD 76952 with a main star of type B, plus 5 t tauri stars , one very large gas giant and 4 rocky planets, only one of which is landable, but with no atmosphere.
That stars with dubious coordinates and which are just over the 500ly limit could actually be closer and therefore reachable.
Many of these coordinates were produced by various Commanders some time ago when accuracy wasn't as critical as now.
This will take some to time to check out, and given the timing of your posts, it seems the Spansh data won't be up-to-date until Sunday at the earliest.
So don't expect any confirmation of completion for the time being !
My last star was HD 76952 with a main star of type B, plus 5 t tauri stars , one very large gas giant and 4 rocky planets, only one of which is landable, but with no atmosphere.
HD 155803 complete. Star and five gas giants.
Progress report ....
a) I have finished proof reading in game all the coordinates of stars marked as unreachable (all 1666 of them).
b) downloaded the latest copy of the spansh db.
c) run the merge program against both a) and b).
d) run the search program for finding any unreachable stars within 500 ly of a known star (on spansh).
And found....
No unaccounted for HIP stars !
Several stars that have been visited recently but have not been matched by the merge program, now under investigation.
Several anomalies that have been around for a long time but always left until "later".
And another big thing I want to check out ...
On a different thread I was reminded that prior to the start of the Glorious HIPs project, there were numerous HIP stars already in EDSM. Some of them only because they had had their coordinates trilaterated, not because they had been visited. This was pointed out because the very highest and lowest HIP stars in EDSM are not in our current lists of HIP stars. This doesn't really matter for the record breakers because they are way out of reach, but these trilaterations were mainly done before the advent of Fleet Carriers. So it is quite feasible that some of these original stars are now within FC reach.
The problem is, identifying HIP stars which have been trilaterated. My first approach will be to identify the HIP stars that have zero bodies, and find the nearest stars to them. That way I may find a number of possible stars to visit. When the HIP project started there were about 90,000 HIP stars already in EDSM, and we have spent 2 years visiting the other 26,000 which were not in EDSM. So I think there is a good chance that some of these early HIPs are now within reach of fleet carriers.
I think the problem of zero bodies has been addressed in other threads, iirc there may be as many as 10,000 such HIP stars in edsm. Hopefully all of them will be out of reach !
I am not looking to prolong this project any longer than necessary, but the aim of the project is to ensure every possible HIP star has been visited.
Anyway, don't expect a final answer in the next couple of weeks. I will try to keep you updated on how I get on with the research.
a) I have finished proof reading in game all the coordinates of stars marked as unreachable (all 1666 of them).
b) downloaded the latest copy of the spansh db.
c) run the merge program against both a) and b).
d) run the search program for finding any unreachable stars within 500 ly of a known star (on spansh).
And found....
No unaccounted for HIP stars !
Several stars that have been visited recently but have not been matched by the merge program, now under investigation.
Several anomalies that have been around for a long time but always left until "later".
And another big thing I want to check out ...
On a different thread I was reminded that prior to the start of the Glorious HIPs project, there were numerous HIP stars already in EDSM. Some of them only because they had had their coordinates trilaterated, not because they had been visited. This was pointed out because the very highest and lowest HIP stars in EDSM are not in our current lists of HIP stars. This doesn't really matter for the record breakers because they are way out of reach, but these trilaterations were mainly done before the advent of Fleet Carriers. So it is quite feasible that some of these original stars are now within FC reach.
The problem is, identifying HIP stars which have been trilaterated. My first approach will be to identify the HIP stars that have zero bodies, and find the nearest stars to them. That way I may find a number of possible stars to visit. When the HIP project started there were about 90,000 HIP stars already in EDSM, and we have spent 2 years visiting the other 26,000 which were not in EDSM. So I think there is a good chance that some of these early HIPs are now within reach of fleet carriers.
I think the problem of zero bodies has been addressed in other threads, iirc there may be as many as 10,000 such HIP stars in edsm. Hopefully all of them will be out of reach !
I am not looking to prolong this project any longer than necessary, but the aim of the project is to ensure every possible HIP star has been visited.
Anyway, don't expect a final answer in the next couple of weeks. I will try to keep you updated on how I get on with the research.
Last edited:
There's already a list of systems with no primary stars on ED Astrometics, it's about 18m systems but it should be a big problem to pull out the HIP systems from that list, I used that to help me clear up the KOI stars.
Thanks, I did know that had been done, but didn't know where the list was.
Not so fast, we definitely need to reconfirm the reachability of stars via fleet carrier more scrupulously. Specifically, while skimming the spreadsheets months ago, I came across a few stars that were marked unreachable, yet I was actually able to find a proc-gen star within 500 ly on the galaxy map. They fall generally into two categories:
1) Some stars were checked carefully, but not carefully enough. It would appear that proc-gen stars stop generating beyond 500 ly directly above or below the catalog star. While this is correct, we ought to check a few hundred light years laterally, since the proc-gen stars may spawn higher or lower than directly above or below the catalog star. It may then be possible to reach the star from one of those proc-gen stars. I have confirmed this in the specific case of HD 47761. The y-value of HD 47761 is -874, while the y-value of the nearest proc-gen star vertically is about -340. Clearly this is greater than 500 ly. At the time, the star was marked unreachable. However, HD 47761 is in the gap of the arm, and I was able to reach the star from a thicker portion of the arm, about a hundred light years laterally. There, the proc-gen stars reached lower, even below -450, and I was able to visit via fleet carrier. See HD 47761 in the galaxy map to understand this better.
2) Some stars were not checked carefully, or determined unreachable before fleet carriers, and there does not exist a proc-gen star in EDDN within 500 ly, yet is obviously reachable upon inspection of the galaxy map. I am aware of a star about 20000 ly from the bubble, in the Formidine Rift, that I know for certainty is not in EDDN, yet is obviously reachable. I believe CMDR Varonica is planning to reach this star so I won't disclose it, and I'm too far away from it to go there for the forseeable future. I am not consciously aware of other instances (though I may have it bookmarked by accident, as I have over 200 bookmarks) but I am confident there's more out there.
One of the problems is we can't check proc-gen stars that aren't in the catalogue to compare them with the currently unreachable stars, that requires manually going to the area and painstakingly searching all surrounding space for possible proc-gen stars within 500ly, above, below and all around, an area of 1000ly in diameter, and that's not easy because they are very hard to spot, many people just don't have the patience for that sort of thing.
Last edited:
I agree, it's more painstaking than I made it sound. I tried this for a few stars and it's quite exhausting.
Ha ! I thought that would get a response.
Sorry if I got you too excited. What I really meant was that HIP 84344 was the last star on our current wanted list, as of yesterday.
So here is our new wanted list .... with some new features. the < route arrows have been enhanced to show the intermediate distance between the two waypoints.
Also, the minimum separation has been increased to 520 ly, to show any that were marginal.
The circular traps mentioned in my earlier post are still there, don't forget that BD+24 3048 , XZ Leonis and Rho Leanis are themselves unreachable(?)
This list was created after the latest updates and revisions to the unreachable stars lists. There were a large number of small corrections, and a couple where the sign was wrong. So it's possible that some easy stars have now been found.
Sorry if I got you too excited. What I really meant was that HIP 84344 was the last star on our current wanted list, as of yesterday.
So here is our new wanted list .... with some new features. the < route arrows have been enhanced to show the intermediate distance between the two waypoints.
Also, the minimum separation has been increased to 520 ly, to show any that were marginal.
The circular traps mentioned in my earlier post are still there, don't forget that BD+24 3048 , XZ Leonis and Rho Leanis are themselves unreachable(?)
This list was created after the latest updates and revisions to the unreachable stars lists. There were a large number of small corrections, and a couple where the sign was wrong. So it's possible that some easy stars have now been found.
Slice | ED name | HIP num | X | Y | Z | Nearest <distance<route | X | Y | Z | distance |
1 | HIP 103248 | HIP 103248 | -33 | -3040 | 3531 | HD 200096<414<HD 200144<519<HD 205046 | -201 | -2993 | 3311 | 280.8 |
1 | HD 197000 | HIP 102184 | -249 | -2872 | 3661 | HIP 103248<281<HD 200096<414<HD 200144<519<HD 205046 | -33 | -3040 | 3531 | 303 |
1 | HD 200096 | HIP 103857 | -201 | -2993 | 3311 | HIP 103248<281<HD 200096<414<HD 200144<519<HD 205046 | -33 | -3040 | 3531 | 280.8 |
1 | HD 210917 | HIP 109808 | -223 | -3659 | 2448 | HIP 110123<515<HD 211744 | -68 | -3890 | 2564 | 301.4 |
1 | HIP 110123 | HIP 110123 | -68 | -3890 | 2564 | HD 212084<291<HIP 110123<515<HD 211744 | -250 | -4116 | 2589 | 291.2 |
1 | HD 212084 | HIP 110455 | -250 | -4116 | 2589 | HIP 110123<515<HD 211744 | -68 | -3890 | 2564 | 291.2 |
2 | HD 196949 | HIP 102107 | -689 | -2379 | 3113 | HD 200144<519<HD 205046 | -477 | -2782 | 3086 | 456.2 |
2 | HD 200144 | HIP 103862 | -477 | -2782 | 3086 | HD 200096<414<HD 200144<519<HD 205046 | -201 | -2993 | 3311 | 413.9 |
5 | HIP 81142 | HIP 81142 | -2681 | 3400 | 3287 | HIP 81245<283<BD+24 3048+ | -2656 | 3325 | 3237 | 93.5 |
5 | HIP 80194 | HIP 80194 | -2203 | 3307 | 3190 | HIP 81245<283<BD+24 3048+ | -2656 | 3325 | 3237 | 455.8 |
5 | HD 221996 | HIP 116531 | -731 | -4291 | 1011 | HD 222194<399<HD 221996<502<HIP 115318 | -1041 | -4521 | 911 | 398.7 |
5 | HIP 81245 | HIP 81245 | -2656 | 3325 | 3237 | HIP 81142<329<BD+24 3048+ | -2681 | 3400 | 3287 | 93.5 |
5 | HIP 79412 | HIP 79412 | -2365 | 3604 | 2866 | HIP 80194<456<HIP 81245<283<BD+24 3048+ | -2203 | 3307 | 3190 | 468.4 |
6 | HIP 78777 | HIP 78777 | -2637 | 3966 | 2620 | HIP 79412<517<HIP 80601<520<HIP 81446 | -2365 | 3604 | 2866 | 515.3 |
6 | HIP 80601 | HIP 80601 | -2478 | 3171 | 2608 | HIP 80551<250<HIP 80601<520<HIP 81446 | -2517 | 3127 | 2365 | 250 |
6 | HD 197953 | HIP 102564 | -3548 | -2493 | 3429 | HD 200138<501<HD 197463 | -3731 | -2572 | 3003 | 470.3 |
6 | HD 219244 | HIP 114747 | -1150 | -4137 | 1235 | HD 221996<502<HIP 115318 | -731 | -4291 | 1011 | 499.5 |
7 | HIP 81674 | HIP 81674 | -3226 | 3502 | 2808 | BD+24 3048+ | -2861 | 3248 | 3058 | 509.5 |
7 | HIP 103722 | HIP 103722 | -4034 | -2820 | 3308 | HD 200138<501<HD 197463 | -3731 | -2572 | 3003 | 496.3 |
7 | HD 222194 | HIP 116661 | -1041 | -4521 | 911 | HD 221996<502<HIP 115318 | -731 | -4291 | 1011 | 398.7 |
7 | HIP 80551 | HIP 80551 | -2517 | 3127 | 2365 | HIP 80601<520<HIP 81446 | -2478 | 3171 | 2608 | 250 |
8 | HD 200138 | HIP 103760 | -3731 | -2572 | 3003 | HIP 104876<322<HD 200138<501<HD 197463 | -3688 | -2742 | 2733 | 321.9 |
8 | HIP 104876 | HIP 104876 | -3688 | -2742 | 2733 | HD 200138<501<HD 197463 | -3731 | -2572 | 3003 | 321.9 |
11 | HIP 104175 | HIP 104175 | -6634 | -2195 | 2475 | Blua Eolls SE-F d12-0 | -6621 | -1699 | 2546 | 501.2 |
13 | HIP 112659 | HIP 112659 | -2933 | -2857 | 530 | HD 217178<474<HD 216452<506<HD 216817 | -2756 | -2779 | 355 | 260.8 |
13 | HD 216452 | HIP 112993 | -2339 | -2661 | 548 | HD 218441<354<HD 216452<506<HD 216817 | -2465 | -2921 | 343 | 354.3 |
14 | HD 218441 | HIP 114230 | -2465 | -2921 | 343 | HD 217178<474<HD 216452<506<HD 216817 | -2756 | -2779 | 355 | 324 |
14 | HIP 113180 | HIP 113180 | -2674 | -2603 | 366 | HD 217178<474<HD 216452<506<HD 216817 | -2756 | -2779 | 355 | 194.5 |
14 | HD 217178 | HIP 113453 | -2756 | -2779 | 355 | HIP 113180<386<HD 216452<506<HD 216817 | -2674 | -2603 | 366 | 194.5 |
15 | HD 221381 | HIP 116116 | -2900 | -3316 | -167 | HIP 116627<209<HD 221381<492<HD 219187<357<HD 217178<474<HD 216452<506<HD 216817 | -2993 | -3298 | -353 | 208.7 |
15 | HIP 115607 | HIP 115607 | -2849 | -2986 | -124 | HD 219187<357<HD 217178<474<HD 216452<506<HD 216817 | -2896 | -2870 | 40 | 206.3 |
15 | HIP 115161 | HIP 115161 | -2933 | -3211 | 42 | HD 221381<492<HD 219187<357<HD 217178<474<HD 216452<506<HD 216817 | -2900 | -3316 | -167 | 236.2 |
15 | HD 219187 | HIP 114676 | -2896 | -2870 | 40 | HIP 115607<206<HD 219187<357<HD 217178<474<HD 216452<506<HD 216817 | -2849 | -2986 | -124 | 206.3 |
16 | HD 222558 | HIP 116886 | -2654 | -3077 | -336 | HIP 115607<206<HD 219187<357<HD 217178<474<HD 216452<506<HD 216817 | -2849 | -2986 | -124 | 302.1 |
16 | HIP 116627 | HIP 116627 | -2993 | -3298 | -353 | HD 221381<492<HD 219187<357<HD 217178<474<HD 216452<506<HD 216817 | -2900 | -3316 | -167 | 208.7 |
20 | HIP 63026 | HIP 63026 | -1201 | 4314 | -681 | HIP 64902 | -1422 | 3901 | -498 | 503.4 |
23 | HD 66772 | HIP 39807 | -1109 | 2297 | -3313 | HD 233568 | -819 | 2436 | -2911 | 515.2 |
24 | HIP 50273 | HIP 50273 | -275 | 3716 | -2576 | HD 86415 | 47 | 3334 | -2524 | 502.4 |
24 | HD 64867 | HIP 38937 | -555 | 2799 | -4627 | HD 62118 | -218 | 2414 | -4575 | 514.8 |
24 | HIP 11508 | HIP 11508 | -100 | -3455 | -2066 | HIP 12476 | -312 | -3181 | -2449 | 516.4 |
25 | HIP 60373 | HIP 60373 | 6 | 4153 | -485 | HIP 60511 | 419 | 4322 | -236 | 510.9 |
25 | HD 23377 | HIP 17479 | 587 | -3217 | -3704 | HD 25647<514<HD 23646 | 1043 | -3020 | -3673 | 497.7 |
26 | HD 25647 | HIP 18985 | 1043 | -3020 | -3673 | HIP 19621<302<HD 25647<514<HD 23646 | 1273 | -3074 | -3861 | 301.9 |
26 | HD 26186 | HIP 19329 | 1194 | -3278 | -4170 | HIP 19621<302<HD 25647<514<HD 23646 | 1273 | -3074 | -3861 | 378.6 |
26 | HIP 19621 | HIP 19621 | 1273 | -3074 | -3861 | HD 25647<514<HD 23646 | 1043 | -3020 | -3673 | 301.9 |
27 | HIP 42056 | HIP 42056 | 1468 | 2446 | -3519 | HD 75750<456<HD 79127<501<HD 76946 | 1680 | 2564 | -3167 | 427.5 |
27 | HD 293852 | HIP 24001 | 2398 | -2533 | -5214 | Scheau Phrae XE-G d11-0 | 2434 | -2017 | -5194 | 517.7 |
28 | HIP 42131 | HIP 42131 | 1962 | 2296 | -3375 | HD 75750<456<HD 79127<501<HD 76946 | 1680 | 2564 | -3167 | 441.1 |
28 | HIP 45074 | HIP 45074 | 1592 | 2594 | -2712 | HD 79127<501<HD 76946 | 1814 | 2669 | -2744 | 236.5 |
28 | HIP 50394 | HIP 50394 | 1182 | 3323 | -1942 | HD 86368<455<HD 89196<363<HD 87412<512<XZ Leonis+ | 1379 | 3343 | -2310 | 417.9 |
28 | HD 86368 | HIP 48900 | 1379 | 3343 | -2310 | HIP 50394<418<HD 86368<455<HD 89196<363<HD 87412<512<XZ Leonis+ | 1182 | 3323 | -1942 | 417.9 |
28 | HD 81540 | HIP 46311 | 1920 | 3044 | -2750 | HD 79127<501<HD 76946 | 1814 | 2669 | -2744 | 389.7 |
28 | HD 79660 | HIP 45473 | 1365 | 2570 | -2570 | HIP 45074<237<HD 79127<501<HD 76946 | 1592 | 2594 | -2712 | 268.8 |
28 | HD 79127 | HIP 45201 | 1814 | 2669 | -2744 | HIP 45074<237<HD 79127<501<HD 76946 | 1592 | 2594 | -2712 | 236.5 |
28 | HIP 42621 | HIP 42621 | 2201 | 2635 | -3659 | HIP 42131<441<HD 75750<456<HD 79127<501<HD 76946 | 1962 | 2296 | -3375 | 502.7 |
28 | HD 75750 | HIP 43564 | 1680 | 2564 | -3167 | HIP 42056<428<HD 75750<456<HD 79127<501<HD 76946 | 1468 | 2446 | -3519 | 427.5 |
29 | HD 87412 | HIP 49410 | 1745 | 3767 | -2402 | HD 89196<363<HD 87412<512<XZ Leonis+ | 1565 | 3698 | -2095 | 362.5 |
29 | HD 89196 | HIP 50425 | 1565 | 3698 | -2095 | HD 87412<512<XZ Leonis+ | 1745 | 3767 | -2402 | 362.5 |
30 | HD 73836 | HIP 42547 | 3181 | 1870 | -2845 | HD 75282<362<HD 73836<509<PSR J0823+0159 | 3306 | 1812 | -2510 | 362.2 |
31 | HD 95936 | HIP 54103 | 1876 | 4310 | -1265 | HD 92731 | 1762 | 4118 | -1716 | 502.8 |
31 | HD 75282 | HIP 43284 | 3306 | 1812 | -2510 | HD 73836<509<PSR J0823+0159 | 3181 | 1870 | -2845 | 362.2 |
31 | HIP 43072 | HIP 43072 | 3564 | 1962 | -2806 | HD 73836<509<PSR J0823+0159 | 3181 | 1870 | -2845 | 395.8 |
32 | HD 91622 | HIP 51787 | 2650 | 4127 | -1655 | Rho Leonis+ | 2697 | 4351 | -1830 | 287.9 |
35 | HIP 37762 | HIP 37762 | 13070 | -2113 | -3067 | Flya Eolls DS-R d5-0 | 12976 | -1625 | -3133 | 501.3 |
42 | HD 110184 | HIP 61824 | 1252 | 4058 | 619 | HIP 60415 | 1114 | 4201 | 158 | 501.7 |
48 | HD 198210 | HIP 103129 | 2447 | -2877 | 3187 | HD 192219<502<HD 186393 | 2068 | -2621 | 3347 | 484.5 |
49 | HD 192219 | HIP 100078 | 2068 | -2621 | 3347 | HD 194420<271<HD 192219<502<HD 186393 | 1806 | -2692 | 3348 | 271.5 |
50 | HD 194420 | HIP 101064 | 1806 | -2692 | 3348 | HD 192219<502<HD 186393 | 2068 | -2621 | 3347 | 271.5 |
51 | HD 191630 | HIP 99758 | 1823 | -2843 | 3816 | HD 189912<301<HD 191630<492<HD 194420<271<HD 192219<502<HD 186393 | 1614 | -2819 | 4031 | 300.8 |
51 | HD 191853 | HIP 99828 | 1795 | -3051 | 4125 | HD 189912<301<HD 191630<492<HD 194420<271<HD 192219<502<HD 186393 | 1614 | -2819 | 4031 | 308.9 |
51 | HD 189912 | HIP 98973 | 1614 | -2819 | 4031 | HD 191630<492<HD 194420<271<HD 192219<502<HD 186393 | 1823 | -2843 | 3816 | 300.8 |
52 | HIP 97535 | HIP 97535 | 1442 | -2426 | 3792 | HD 189912<301<HD 191630<492<HD 194420<271<HD 192219<502<HD 186393 | 1614 | -2819 | 4031 | 491.1 |
52 | HD 136105 | HIP 75007 | 1844 | 2493 | 5055 | Blau Treia EH-K d9-0 | 2022 | 2068 | 4859 | 500.7 |
55 | HD 208757 | HIP 108556 | 130 | -3752 | 2873 | HIP 110123<515<HD 211744 | -68 | -3890 | 2564 | 392.1 |
55 | HIP 65364 | HIP 65364 | 17 | 3919 | 678 | HIP 66395 | -153 | 3433 | 699 | 514.9 |
Last edited:
I will be posting links to the updated master spreadsheets soon.
Including the overall unreachable stars list with the current known nearest neighbour included.
Edit: I have to admit there is one line missing from the above table. It looks like an easy jump from a known star.
Probably newly found because of the sign error I mentioned. It's not that far from where I am, so I'm on my way.
Including the overall unreachable stars list with the current known nearest neighbour included.
Edit: I have to admit there is one line missing from the above table. It looks like an easy jump from a known star.
Probably newly found because of the sign error I mentioned. It's not that far from where I am, so I'm on my way.
Last edited:
Although I'm too far away from the bubble to go to these stars, I did determine which stars are reachable via proc-gen stars. I didn't look at the other stars though.
HIP 104175 is trivially reachable from Blua Eolls QT-G d11-0 (unexplored). Their distance is ~400 ly from visual inspection.
HD 293852 is NOT reachable by a proc-gen star. The listed star is the closest.
HIP 37762 is reachable from Flya Eolls IY-P d6-0 (unexplored). Their distance is ~489.1 ly from the distance formula.
HD 136105 is trivially reachable from Blau Treia JT-G d11-0 (unexplored). Their distance is ~400 ly from visual inspection.
Looking forward to the next spreadsheet.
HIP 104175 is trivially reachable from Blua Eolls QT-G d11-0 (unexplored). Their distance is ~400 ly from visual inspection.
HD 293852 is NOT reachable by a proc-gen star. The listed star is the closest.
HIP 37762 is reachable from Flya Eolls IY-P d6-0 (unexplored). Their distance is ~489.1 ly from the distance formula.
HD 136105 is trivially reachable from Blau Treia JT-G d11-0 (unexplored). Their distance is ~400 ly from visual inspection.
Looking forward to the next spreadsheet.
Last edited:
As promised, here is the link to the latest spreadsheet of unreachable stars.
On line 1597 it has HIP 75007 as just 500.7 ly from Blau Treia EH-K d9-0 .
Anyway, good hunting .... > Unreachable stars <
On line 1597 it has HIP 75007 as just 500.7 ly from Blau Treia EH-K d9-0 .
Anyway, good hunting .... > Unreachable stars <
Given your expertise with finding these proc-gen stars, have a go with the spreadsheet above.
It contains every HIP currently marked as unreachable.
It is ordered by distance within each slice. Some are very close like the one I mentioned.
I will be having a go myself as my carrier scoots off to somewhere near HD 120296.
edit; that was easy, Blau Treia HN-I d10-0 is way closer to HIP 75007 than Blau Treia EH-K d9-0 !
They are not far from where I'm going either, so should pick them them in next few days.
II have placed a marker in the > Unreachable stars < spreadsheet. You should be able to add closer stars in there as well.
Last edited:
There were a couple of stars I visited that were literally surrounded by procgen stars and had never been visited, I mean it's quite possible no-one had managed to get within 500ly until recently so just relying on stars already cataloged wouldn't tell you there were stars within 30ly of the target if all stars in a radius of 500ly had never been visited, so yes these will continue to pop us as the galaxy is explored.