I hope DW2 gets ganked all the way to Beagle Point.

Historical imperative.

If I interpret your avatar correctly, you of all people should understand that.

And also completely irrelevant, as even a high sec system wouldn't prevent ganks. Bless FD for the complete uselessness of security ratings.
 
I agree with that. Fly open, build for open. Live with the consequences if not.

But I also agree with reinstating ships by gankers in a PG without PvP. That is griefing, plain and simple.

I hope we get a lot of that (sorry to the players who get destroyed in that, though) so that FD will have to take a stance on that one.

Infiltrating a PG to cause harm is unacceptable for me, and I hope there will be consequences.

Agreed 300%
 
Yes, I guess this could create a precedent for Mobius for example, empowering members to request restores whenever there is any foul play. Just the number of tickets alone would shake things up a little.

I'm kinda rooting for this to happen now.

Everyone is empowered to request a restore.

https://support.frontier.co.uk/kb/

Nobody is entitled to receive a restore - not in open, not in solo, not in Mobius and not in Fleetcomm. Rule violations in a PG will be judged and decided on a case by case basis. But you all know FD support. they're great.
 
If this ganking is 'expected' in Open then surely you just need to up the crime and punishment.

I mean yes it is one thing attacking/pirating ships going to CG's etc. part of the game/part of the universe.

But this is more akin to someone turning up at the start of the Tour de france with an AK and just opening up - that should be met with deadly force by all of the ED security services for a good few months for any identified commanders

Probably not going to happen though.
 
Last edited:
If this ganking is 'expected' in Open then surely you just need to up the crime and punishment.

I mean yes it is one thing attacking/pirating ships going to CG's etc. part of the game/part of the universe.

But this is more akin to someone turning up at the start of the Tour de france with an AK and just opening up - that should be met with deadly force by all of the ED security services for a good few months for any identified commanders

Probably not going to happen though.

Except they decided to hold it in a low security system, like the tour setting of from Somalia.
 
If this ganking is 'expected' in Open then surely you just need to up the crime and punishment.

I mean yes it is one thing attacking/pirating ships going to CG's etc. part of the game/part of the universe.

But this is more akin to someone turning up at the start of the Tour de france with an AK and just opening up - that should be met with deadly force by all of the ED security services for a good few months for any identified commanders

Probably not going to happen though.
I always thought it would be interesting if notoriety acquired from PvP interactions was permanent, even after ship destruction. They should try that in the next beta. Surely that would up that challenge factor that PvPers are always talking about, right?
 
If the PG's rules actually prohibited PKing, then player damage would be turned off. But it is not turned off. So PKing is perfectly fine despite the arbitrary rules. It is incumbent on the owners of the PG to kick from the group people who PK. It is not incumbent on FDev to do so.

You are confusing kicking with restoring ships.
 
The system was chosen, as another poster indicated, due to the history of the event and where it started from.
 
I always thought it would be interesting if notoriety acquired from PvP interactions was permanent, even after ship destruction. They should try that in the next beta. Surely that would up that challenge factor that PvPers are always talking about, right?

The problem with that is the ramming "exploit". I guess a lot of CMDRs would come in whining here why their notoriety would be permanent if they speed in a NFZ and ram a poor eagle to death. But we digress.
 
Im a mobius carebear ever since i heard it existed...

But something feels really wrong about frontier offering to restore player ships.. its just a little bit too god hand. It doesn't feel right.

I understand that someone said somewhere that pvpers used the sale to buy throwaway accounts just to troll people going.. but it may have been a better experience to keep people aware it may happen rather than padded walling it.

Its not wrong given there's no pve mode but its not right either. Frontiers customer support team are the only group left who exceed expectations so poor them.

Yeah depending on how many trojan players are actually going along..

Weren't they organising a whole heap of support commanders for dw2.. why not a protection squad as well. I always remember there were angel combat groups as well as troll pvpers.

To me it looks like they cheated* their way into the PG.

*cheating as in lying in your résumé.
 
The problem with that is the ramming "exploit". I guess a lot of CMDRs would come in whining here why their notoriety would be permanent if they speed in a NFZ and ram a poor eagle to death. But we digress.
If they can’t read the radar well enough to see it coming, then I’d argue that they deserve it. It’s not rocket science (well, I mean technically it sort of is, but not the complicated kind of rocket science).
 
The system was chosen, as another poster indicated, due to the history of the event and where it started from.

Then if they wouldn't change venue they could at least of done some 'prep' work and played the BGS to change the security/ownership of said system.

The difference in security and ATR response times in a low sec system is significant and only made the gankers jobs easier. Or feed them kills, whatever you prefer.
 
Then if they wouldn't change venue they could at least of done some 'prep' work and played the BGS to change the security/ownership of said system.

The difference in security and ATR response times in a low sec system is significant and only made the gankers jobs easier. Or feed them kills, whatever you prefer.

Most of the explorer builds ganked in open yesterday wouldn't survive the 10 seconds it takes an ATR to arrive in high sec. So that's useless.
 
Last edited:
If the servers had been working properly, we had a few guys who wanted to come for some griefer griefing, but I'm done banging my head against this net code, I played some pro evo soccer instead.

Back to wondering why 15 people doing inf missions isn't making any difference to the factions influence.
 
Agree with your whole post, but the notion of protection escort pilots was always a fantasy
It's doable in specific circumstances, but usefully protecting an entire 11,000-pilot expedition is indeed impossible [1].

To even have an escort ship in the "right" instance you'd need probably about a quarter of the expedition to be escorts. Good luck vetting 2,500 combat pilots in a hurry...

As it is I haven't seen/heard about a single actual escort combat ship doing anything, although I suppose that doesn't mean they didn't try
It doesn't mean they didn't succeed, either - sneaking explorers in safely isn't glamorous work and if done well no-one much knows it happened, but it's quite a bit more effective than the fantasies people have about rescuing people from an actual fight.



[1] Equally, the chances of any individual explorer getting attacked are also pretty low. But "10,000 explorers not blown up by hostiles" won't be the headline if that happens.
 
Everyone is empowered to request a restore.

https://support.frontier.co.uk/kb/

Nobody is entitled to receive a restore - not in open, not in solo, not in Mobius and not in Fleetcomm. Rule violations in a PG will be judged and decided on a case by case basis. But you all know FD support. they're great.

That's exactly my point, players wouldn't necessarily receive a restore, but currently they aren't really flocking to support whenever a ship is lost due to another player, are they? They just contact Mobius, provide whatever evidence they have to get that player removed, and that is the end of the story. Because this procedure has been set up with the firm belief that FDEV will never, under any circumstances, restore player assets lost to another player.

What would happen if Mobius players were actively encouraged to contact support for any ship loss caused by another player? With this new episode in the Elite Saga serving as precedent?

Even if the chance of getting a restore would be practically null, I know I still would ask for one, given the precedent. How hard is it to write an e-mail after all?

Would the number of e-mails make any impact with the support team? Would it shake things up, maybe shake up some exec chair high in FDEV? Would they need to hire one guy in support to handle the workload, guy which could have been doing the kind of work Mobius has been doing for years for free, and which FDEV have been reaping the fruits of?
 
Then if they wouldn't change venue they could at least of done some 'prep' work and played the BGS to change the security/ownership of said system.
The ability of BGS work to change security levels is pretty minimal, once the system isn't under Anarchy control. Some 'Low' security can be increased to 'Medium' in theory, but only by putting them into Lockdown which has its own downsides.
 
If the devs are actually restoring ships, data, assets of official DW2 participants, and well known PKrs are either friends with or members of the related PGs - I think this would be a great opportunity to actually demonstrate the profound annoyance a PK gank event actually represents.

Let me be clear. The rules permit this gameplay - there is no moral deficit expressed by the players that exercise the rules as they see fit.

If, however, the devs are jammed restoring hundreds or even thousands of player data sets over the several month journey - perhaps - just maybe - a tiny glimmer of possibility here - FDEV will realize that an OPEN PVE mode is actually a good thing.

So you 5th column nefarios, jackals and wolves following the wide-eyed and eager explorers - here's to you. Shoot straight, shoot often and may your cargo holds fill with more salt than even you can carry. TALLY HO!

Open PVE is basically what powerplay is though strung across all modes.

Its why Braben said it would never work when asked in the past. Because people are eventually supposed to be losing things.

Its cool these are organized in PG's and Kudos to the crazy dudes with those paper long range ships in open.
 
Back
Top Bottom