I am still very much on the fence regarding this whole debacle as I have had high hopes and expectations for ED, but I must admit that after the revelations of the past days, my once solid confidence in FD has suffered a massive blow.
Here's why...
1 the reason for this gigantaur of a thread: Eliminating offline option
2 the exceptionally poor communications effort by FD officials ( I do not refer to the forum moderators here )
The following have just come to my attention after reading through the entirety of this thread (yes, all 285 pages)
3 ingame advertising, this is to me completely intolerable in the form mentioned several times in this thread.
4 no option for a 'private' game world/galaxy, as online solo is apparently affected by all players ("blaze your own trail..." on the heels of 100000 others ??)
now, add that to the current state of this project. (I could reiterate a list as long as a runway, but I'll spare you )
All in all, FD now has 2 gigantic tasks ahead of them, and very little time to do so:
1 find a solution to the offine issue, and clearly communicate said solution to the people paying their salaries.
2 deliver what they have promised on 16-12 at the latest, that being at the very least a 100% functional game experience.
Failure to accomplish either will have grim consequences for both game and developer.*
*note of clarification: this is meant as a warning, NOT a threat, I simply foresee the community/customer/press reactions.