It had crossed my mind, but I have no evidence for it, that the Thargoids might be looking for Raxxla too and that was why they were in the Pleiades.. pure speculation, but one should ask why the big interest in that region by both major powers and the thargoids..
 

Scytale

Banned
Might be in line with the limits FD put on the ED writers: no Thargs, no Raxxla... and no antigravity.
mmmhhh... are these linked in some way ?
 
It had crossed my mind, but I have no evidence for it, that the Thargoids might be looking for Raxxla too and that was why they were in the Pleiades.. pure speculation, but one should ask why the big interest in that region by both major powers and the thargoids..
Hmm... that sounds a little bit like slipping over into seeing Raxxla everywhere and ignoring what's really there. Which is what they want. ;)

There's various reasons for the Superpowers to be there. Primarily there's the presence of a very valuable resource - Meta-Alloys. There's also obviously military reasons to be there. All these start with the Thargoids.

The Thargoid presence goes back to the end of the first war, where they had left the seeds of their own return.

Why would they be in the Pleiades in the first place? Well Thargoids sow areas then return later. Other areas with Barnacles are the Witchhead and California Nebulas. Why Nebulae? Well that's open to speculation, but possibly it's down to deposition on surfaces of the molecules which compose the Nebula.

Anyway... The rumours have always been that it's Soontill the Thargoids were looking for, not Raxxla.
 

Scytale

Banned
Thargoids appear in the FDEV sanctioned books, which are supposed to be canon.

Of course, but not in an "active" way.
I mean, in order to deal with Raxxla, we might be supposed to deal with the Thargs and antigravity in some manner...
What do we know about Tharg drives ? Are they "Newtonian" like ours ? And Raxxla ?
Anyway... just guessing.
 
Last edited:
Of course, but not in an "active" way.
I mean, in order to deal with Raxxla, we might be supposed to deal with the Thargs and antigravity in some manner...
What do we know about Tharg drives ? Are they "Newtonian" like ours ? And Raxxla ?
Anyway... just guessing.
Out Of The Darkness has Thargoids in an active way. Unless by active you mean that things are told from a Thargoid perspective.
 
He has everyone convinced that there is not going to be any clues what-so-ever in any of the books because Raxxla was 'strictly off-limits' to him. I am not saying he isn't a credible source, what I am saying is if he was cut from writing about Raxxla that is one thing, but he gave his position as if he were speaking for every 3rd party writer there ever was. I am not so sure that Drew has the power and/or knowledge to make such a call without confirming with other authors as well, that kind of statement would have to come from above him or from every writer.

Regardless lets suppose Drew is right and no one is allowed to touch Raxxla, there is still a way to write about Raxxla indirectly without directly referring to the planet or even know you are writing about Raxxla. For example: Suppose I am John Harper writing 'And Here the Wheel'. If I was told I could write about a super-weapon called 'Starburst' with suspected capabilities of blowing up a star, that in and of itself is not directly referring to Raxxla. However... If Raxxla is in a system where the star was exploded, turned into a blackhole, or Raxxla was turned into an asteroid belt, then said weapon is the key to unlocking Raxxla. I like Drew, he's a good guy, I just wish he wouldn't have made such a blanket statement convincing people there is nothing to Raxxla.
 
He has everyone convinced that there is not going to be any clues what-so-ever in any of the books because Raxxla was 'strictly off-limits' to him. I am not saying he isn't a credible source, what I am saying is if he was cut from writing about Raxxla that is one thing, but he gave his position as if he were speaking for every 3rd party writer there ever was. I am not so sure that Drew has the power and/or knowledge to make such a call without confirming with other authors as well, that kind of statement would have to come from above him or from every writer.

Regardless lets suppose Drew is right and no one is allowed to touch Raxxla, there is still a way to write about Raxxla indirectly without directly referring to the planet or even know you are writing about Raxxla. For example: Suppose I am John Harper writing 'And Here the Wheel'. If I was told I could write about a super-weapon called 'Starburst' with suspected capabilities of blowing up a star, that in and of itself is not directly referring to Raxxla. However... If Raxxla is in a system where the star was exploded, turned into a blackhole, or Raxxla was turned into an asteroid belt, then said weapon is the key to unlocking Raxxla. I like Drew, he's a good guy, I just wish he wouldn't have made such a blanket statement convincing people there is nothing to Raxxla.

There was a writers guide for all the authors. They all had the same information and limitations.

If I remeber correctly, Harper made Soontil because Raxxla was of limits.
 
The picture of the Dark Wheel station in the codex is interesting to me.
  • The star is a very deep red
  • It looks quite big for something presumably far away
  • Most 'M' stars are too small to have anything but snowballs

I visited a bunch of K, M, L, T, Y, C stars to check the color. The K, M (Red Dwarf), Tauri and C stars I checked were much more yellow. L and Y were too purple.
The closest match to color that I could find were M (Red Giant) and M (Red Super Giant). They are also quite big.

Based on that, I ran a search on the EDSM data for Red Giant/Red Super Giant WITH a Gas Giant that has at least 8 moons. I found 41 results.
Does anyone want to help check these? I want to try flying around the 8th moon at close range and seeing if anything pops up.

Zaurak - checked: zaurak c 2 h, non-landable icy body, already mapped. mapping & flying around it didn't expose anything
4 Cassiopeiae - checked: 4 Cassiopeiae AB 2 F, G and H could all have a claim as the "8th moon". Mapping & flying around them didn't expose anything
Shui Wei Sector FC-U b3-3 - BCD 1 H already mapped, mapping & flying around didn't expose anything
Smojue TE-I b23-4
Blu Euq FT-K b49-16
HR 6001
Thueche XK-B c2-6
Dryooe Flyou KE-M b23-45 > by colonia, near interesting black hole Dryooe Flyou PC-V E2-457
NGC 2682 FBC 3456 > S class star - CMDR Macros Black is En Route to Scan
21 Zeta Cephei - Scanned & checked by CMDR Macros Black, nothing found in orbit
Dumboi HM-D d12-26 > Neutron
Synuefe JS-G b44-0 - M3, M8, ABC 2 H, landable, mapped, flew around, nothing
Ploi Aewsy PB-S b31-11
Juenio IS-K d8-900
Eol Flyou ZU-G d10-270
HD 14284 - M5, CMDR Macros Black is En Route to Scan
Floarph JC-D d12-5 - M5 star
Wepua MV-Y d3028 - M5 star
Aucofs HK-A d4
Aucofs QR-W d1-3 - M5 star
Slegou HX-L d7-4
Sleguae YW-B d13-1
Ploea Eurl BM-C b27-0 - M7 star
Byeia Eurk QR-T c17-21 - M8 star
Swoiwns QS-Q b7-0
Spoihaae WS-D b18-8 - M8 star
Col 173 Sector NO-P b35-1 - M8, Mapped and flew around 4 H, nothing found
Floadu JK-A d0
Synuefe CA-K b56-8 - M8, 9 H mapped, flew around, nothing
Gru Hypue JY-I d9-90
Synuefai KP-V b49-5 - M8, Mapped & flew around 8 H but nothing happened
Stuelou EN-Q b36-8 - M8
Eoch Pruae KY-I d9-2322
Byeia Thai VT-Z d13-0
Prua Phoea XF-O d6-21
Bleia Eohn AU-A b33-3 - M3+ M8
Traikaae QY-M b12-0 - M8

I pasted all these into the galaxy map, they all have population 0 and economy: None.
I'd be surprised if finding their station is this simple (eg, maybe it only appears if you have the invite from The Real Dark Wheel or some special permit), but it can't hurt to rule out the known systems.

FWIW I'm triple elite, king, admiral & allied with TDW and all factions that are known to grant system permits

Edit: Cmdr Macros Black is en route to some (thanks!), added notes with some of the darker colored stars (M8 is pretty dark)

Edit 2:
I ran a query for ordinary Red Dwarf stars + gas giant + 8 moons in the same system and came back with 7658 results, so that's not good.

However, I flew toward a Red Super Giant and a Red Dwarf to see how close you have to be for them to look like the picture:
Red Super Giant (Pegasi 2) - Textures still visible, star is a little too small at about 1000 ls away
Red Giant - Textures not visible until about 25 ls, star is still small until under 15 ls
Red Dwarf - Textures not visible until about 25 ls, star is still small until under 10 ls

How can we search for gas giants that have 8 or more moons and to see their distance from star at same time? Because closest gas giant with 8 moons I found was 217 Ls away from M-type star (red dwarf) and it still was too far away to produce image from Codex (Dark Wheel station).
 
Maybe not all know there is already thread focused to searching for the Dark Wheel station using Codex picture as main clue. We already did some work.
https://forums.frontier.co.uk/showthread.php/477422-The-codex-screenshot-for-the-The-Dark-Wheel-Which-system-is-it

I like this thread about Raxxla for wonderful theories based on history, literature, old games. Often clever/studied theories I really enjoy to read all time :) But it is not how we do searching for the station using that Codex picture. It is just about brute force searching and routine. Of course if you can see something more from the Codex picture you are welcome. We need decrease number of candidate systems.
 

Scytale

Banned
Thargoids are Ok.
Raxxla, antigravity and time-travel are off limits.

Thargs nope.
please, don't make me look again for DW's stream telling it, ;)
Saying "again" because the link is already somewhere here.

(Drew ! Help !)

Out Of The Darkness has Thargoids in an active way. Unless by active you mean that things are told from a Thargoid perspective.

I mean like unfolding a plot that implies Thargs coming out of a mere background.
Like Cmdr Scytale Tleilaxu marrying the Tharg Queen or so ..
 
Last edited:
Maybe not all know there is already thread focused to searching for the Dark Wheel station using Codex picture as main clue. We already did some work.
https://forums.frontier.co.uk/showthread.php/477422-The-codex-screenshot-for-the-The-Dark-Wheel-Which-system-is-it

I like this thread about Raxxla for wonderful theories based on history, literature, old games. Often clever/studied theories I really enjoy to read all time :) But it is not how we do searching for the station using that Codex picture. It is just about brute force searching and routine. Of course if you can see something more from the Codex picture you are welcome. We need decrease number of candidate systems.

I like the work in the thread, CMDR. Link to the thread is now added to the OP.
 
Question for anyone who has managed to read the sonnets that may be related to the Raxxla codex entry. Taking a step back I think I’ve been looking at things too fragmentedly. Assuming Omphalos and Astrophel and the Spiriling Stars to be different clues.
The Omphalos Rift is said to be mentioned in several stories which seem to originate in an unnamed book that bares a resemblance to the children’s book “Princess Astrophel and the Spiriling Stars” (I think we often forget the Princess part, dunno if it’s significant tho.) so it would seem that we are to look for a mention of an item of significance, power, Magic etc within the works for a clue(s). Has anyone found mention of an item matching that description within the sonnets?
 
Sign me up initially for:
21 Zeta Cephei
NGC 2682 FBC 3456
HD 14284

Can you update your list with CMDR names as to minimize overlap. If I encounter more from the list on the way southbound, I'll check those too.
I'll check HR 6001 next time I log on. As for narrowing down the list, I would suggest the following criteria:
if stellar_radius less than or equal to 1.0, then distance to gas giant with 8+ moons must be 100ls or less
if stellar_radius greater than 1.0, then distance to gas giant with 8+ moons must be 1500ls or less
This is because there are some stars labelled as red giants in the Stellar Forge even though they have stats resembling red dwarfs (e.g. the system in Bleia Eohn in the list) and the others are much larger than Sol, so the above should separate the two groups quite well.
.
This being said, a red dwarf system would need the gas giant to be so close to the star that the station would be more easily found by passers-by (unless it was a very distant secondary star). Red giants would also attract the attention of explorers. From that perspective, it might be fruitful to search for systems where the gas giant with 8+ moons is close to a star other than the primary, especially in those thousands of systems with a red dwarf primary star. The catch here is that if the gas giant does orbit a star other than the primary, then the initial search needs to cover star types other than type M in order to find which have red dwarf companions!
 
HD 14284 3 H & 4 H

No station found at HD 14284 3 H. Colour not quite right.
20AfeEi.jpg

No station either at 4 H
beN90fQ.jpg
 
Last edited:
No station or other POI at HR 6001. From near the 8th moon, the gas giant and the star are both a decent match in terms of size to the image in the Codex, although the image in the Codex shows more detail on the star and the star appears more red than here. (The star is M2III and is over 51 solar radii and the gas giant is about 1 Kls away).
 
The Omphalos stone is a stone. The Omphalos Rift is... a rift o_O What is rift? The central rift? The central hole?

Being a structure/object of some kind I assume it’s something along the lines of stargate. Why it’s omphalos idk. Central to the planet? Sends you to a center? Central to the galmap? (Which would be sol which sits at coordnace 0:0:0) idk that part I really don’t have a clue on.
 
Back
Top Bottom