If you die 10 times per night due to real oppositon you will fail your BGS stop pretending you dont understand. The modes are an unfair advantage, stop giving me excuses that "PvP is useless in BGS".
The fundamental problem you're having here is that what you want the game to be is clearly not what the people who actually create the game want it to be. Once you accept that fact, all you're doing every time you get wound up enough about it to pile into a thread on here is torturing yourself for no reason because you are never, ever going to get what you want.
I'm going to say this very clearly so you understand it and don't go off on a tangent. I am NOT saying that what you want this aspect of the game to be is 'wrong'. It can't be 'wrong' any more than it can be 'right' because it's entirely subjective.
On top of that, it might surprise you but I actually lean quite strongly towards thinking that powerplay
should probably have been open-only. Reason being it's about the only content in the game that actually provides some sort of coherent structure for activity that's a naturally good fit with PVP. I think it was actually a huge missed opportunity to deliver
exactly the 'meaningful' PVP that DB talked about back in the day.
But they didn't.
It ain't going to change. Not now. Doesn't matter how much you think it would help, doesn't matter how much fun you think it would be, doesn't matter how lame you think it is now. If making powerplay primarily an open activity could somehow cure cancer and unlock the secrets of cold fusion, they still wouldn't do it.
Understanding doesn't change that either.
Seriously, if you have even one iota of hope that it
might change, try to lose it as fast as possible because all you're going to do is get increasingly furious and bitter about it when it doesn't. And it won't.
A PVP player should know better than anyone how stupid it is to waste energy and resources on a fight that you can never win. If I was you, I'd pick a different battle because surely by now you can see that this one is only ever going to bring you disappointment.