But what they are doing is called emergent game play, like when your annoying little brother kicks over your sand castle because he doesn't want to make one and doesn't want you to enjoy yours. He's now the sand castle monster, so now your game play experience is multidimensional. Thanks lil' bro!This is a fair question. In most MMOs there are pvp pve partition mechanics in the open environment. In this game, that partition mechanic is the block list. Within a strictly faction based pvp environment (CZs) you are there to fight intentionally.
If I am doing coop AX base fighting, or grinding mats at a Guardian ruin, visiting a newly discovered lore site (while meeting the like minded-curious), running a multicrew, or cooping a Pirate 7, getting an FSD special at Deciat, I don't need the nuisance commander trollin for lulz. They aren't there to pirate cargo, they are there to hobo. That's fine, they are using the mechanics as designed, and so am I.
Passive aggressive griefing?Looks like blocking is reverse griefing
Well it was specifically set up as an antigriefing policy as stated by Sir David.Looks like blocking is reverse griefing
Not really the same, as in real life you can have a word in their shell and they will pack it in.But what they are doing is called emergent game play, like when your annoying little brother kicks over your sand castle because he doesn't want to make one and doesn't want you to enjoy yours. He's now the sand castle monster, so now your game play experience is multidimensional. Thanks lil' bro!
Until you publish the blurred list of blocked commanders on this forum. Then it becomes its own version of griefing.Well it was specifically set up as an antigriefing policy as stated by Sir David.
Frontier doesn't allow this, because they don't allow naming and shaming. What people do in discords and reddits is another matter of course.Until you publish the blurred list of blocked commanders on this forum. Then it becomes its own version of griefing.
The list is blurred so it might as well be MS Paint.Frontier doesn't allow this, because they don't allow naming and shaming. What people do in discords and reddits is another matter of course.
Having said that: Bending "I don't want to play with you" toward griefing is... an interesting excercise to say the least. Well done, her is your gold star!
Not entirely apparently. People have been banned for stuff they posted in unrelated Discord channels.Frontier doesn't allow this, because they don't allow naming and shaming. What people do in discords and reddits is another matter of course.
[...]
Are you alluding to the slavers? Other than that, places like the combat loggers reddit come to mind. Plenty of unpunished naming and shaming there.Not entirely apparently. People have been banned for stuff they posted in unrelated Discord channels.
Imagine having had your fee fee's hurt 165 times.![]()
You took the bait.
I have not been ganked 165 times.
Pop into a system, scan all the ships. FSDI, Gromboms, Wanted, + Burst builds, - insta block. Leave a station, scan all the ships inside looking for the same gear - insta block. See the system chat with Commanders touting their gank prowess, insta block. At a CG or exploration site with the same features - insta block.
I never block anyone at a CZ though. That's fair spot pvp imo.
Just using the game mechanics as designed. Hope that doesn't hurt your fee fees.
Except that the block function doesn't always work, is really just an instancing filter, and really mucks up the works in the instance for all the other people in it.Me deciding I don't want to spend time with you isn't my fee fees being hurt, it's quality assurance functioning as intended.
One could (rightfully) argue that blocking is, in fact, passive aggressive griefing.Looks like blocking is reverse griefing
Are you saying, just like that, Bob's my uncle?One could (rightfully) argue that blocking is, in fact, passive aggressive griefing.
Short scenario:
I'm friends with CMDR Bob. I like Bob. You're his nephew. CMDR Bob and I want to get together at Space Station Steve to do some mission running and emote to our hearts content in Steve's bar. I jump into the system and dock at the Triple S. CMDR Bob says he's there but I can't find him. We spend the next twenty minutes logging in, logging out, trying to instance together. It never works out, we get frustrated and both log off, grumpy.
The issue? CMDR Bob and I occasionally PvP at the Triple S. The other night, I logged off early and Bob sat in the station, reading GalNet. CMDR HallMonitor over here scanned his build, blocked him because fEe FeE's and gWeeFuR. CMDR HallMonitor was in the instance with me. I saw him. But CMDR Bob had no way of knowing he'd been blocked by CMDR HallMonitor, nor would I have had any reason to think, so CMDR HallMonitor ruined our evening and all he had to do was play future crime in the mailslot.
If you don't want PvP, stay in Private or solo and quit mucking up the instancing in Open.
kthnkbye.
Are you saying, just like that, Bob's my uncle?
That comparison is wrong.One could (rightfully) argue that blocking is, in fact, passive aggressive griefing.
Short scenario:
I'm friends with CMDR Bob. I like Bob. You're his nephew. CMDR Bob and I want to get together at Space Station Steve to do some mission running and emote to our hearts content in Steve's bar. I jump into the system and dock at the Triple S. CMDR Bob says he's there but I can't find him. We spend the next twenty minutes logging in, logging out, trying to instance together. It never works out, we get frustrated and both log off, grumpy.
The issue? CMDR Bob and I occasionally PvP at the Triple S. The other night, I logged off early and Bob sat in the station, reading GalNet. CMDR HallMonitor over here scanned his build, blocked him because fEe FeE's and gWeeFuR. CMDR HallMonitor was in the instance with me. I saw him. But CMDR Bob had no way of knowing he'd been blocked by CMDR HallMonitor, nor would I have had any reason to think, so CMDR HallMonitor ruined our evening and all he had to do was play future crime in the mailslot.
If you don't want PvP, stay in Private or solo and quit mucking up the instancing in Open.
kthnkbye.
The other night, I logged off early and Bob sat in the station, reading GalNet. CMDR HallMonitor over here scanned his build, blocked him because fEe FeE's and gWeeFuR. CMDR HallMonitor was in the instance with me. I saw him.
Except it doesn't work like that at all. Matchmaking will prioritise wing members over blocks, allowing Bob to get into your instance even if he's blocked by HallMonitor.One could (rightfully) argue that blocking is, in fact, passive aggressive griefing.
Short scenario:
I'm friends with CMDR Bob. I like Bob. You're his nephew. CMDR Bob and I want to get together at Space Station Steve to do some mission running and emote to our hearts content in Steve's bar. I jump into the system and dock at the Triple S. CMDR Bob says he's there but I can't find him. We spend the next twenty minutes logging in, logging out, trying to instance together. It never works out, we get frustrated and both log off, grumpy.
The issue? CMDR Bob and I occasionally PvP at the Triple S. The other night, I logged off early and Bob sat in the station, reading GalNet. CMDR HallMonitor over here scanned his build, blocked him because fEe FeE's and gWeeFuR. CMDR HallMonitor was in the instance with me. I saw him. But CMDR Bob had no way of knowing he'd been blocked by CMDR HallMonitor, nor would I have had any reason to think, so CMDR HallMonitor ruined our evening and all he had to do was play future crime in the mailslot.
If you don't want PvP, stay in Private or solo and quit mucking up the instancing in Open.
kthnkbye.