New 25 essential habitat animals META-WISHLIST

[leehonglocal]

Promoted Out: Prezewalski Wild horse
New Entry: Red River Hog

What made the red river hogs New Entry?

 

[becks474]

What made the red river hogs New Entry?

From his list the Przewalski Horse came to the game so now heute replaced it from his list with the red River hog

 

[random goat]

Alright addressing some stuff while I get everything sorted:

Update after the new Conservation Pack.

1. Black Rhinoceros
2. American Black Bear (with Spirit color too)
3. Amur Leopard < Palla's Cat
4. Markhor
5. American Bighorn Sheep
6. Canadian Mountain Goat
7. Pacific Walrus
8. Elephant Seal
9. Leopard Seal
10. Wolverine
11. Takin
12. Golden Snub Nose Monkey
13. Sea otter
14. Przewalski's Wild Horse
15. Javan Rhinoceros
16. Sumatran Tiger
17. Sumatran Rhinoceros
18. Dromedary Camel
19. Gaur
20. Asian Lion
21. Nilgai
22. Great Eland
23. Sloth Bears
24. Spectacled Bear
25. Gibbons

Please quote your original list so I can verify it. I won't add add anything until you post your quote.

Ok i'll update my list because this is getting messy but that is my last post. I've got the horse so i'll add just one new animal: West Indian Manatee

UPDATED LIST:

1. Black rhinoceros
2. African leopard
3. Scarlet Ibis
4. Ocelot
5. Golden Pheasant
6. Emu
7. Greater Rhea
8. Maned wolf
9. Grey crowned crane
10. Secretary bird
11. Marabou stork
12. Sloth (any kind)
11. Nile crocodile
12. Greater Kudu
13. West Indian Manatee
14. Red River Hog
15. Iberian ibex
16. Markhor
17. White cheeked gibbon
18. Golden snub nosed monkey
19. Black howler monkey
20. Mantled guereza
21. Caracal
22. Mandarin duck
23. Sloth bear
24. Blackbuck

And i just realized i added the black rhino twice (i was missing one final animal) so...

25. Giant Armadillo

And i would love to remove the iberian ibex (since another ibex is no longer a priority for me) but i know is against the rules so i'll just regret it eternally

Yeah sorry Iberian ibex stands. I swapped the black rhino though.

1. Flying birds (Obviously)
2. baboon
3. Fossa
4. Coati
5. Blue Wildebeest
6. Red River hogs
7. Manned wolf
8. One type of Mongoose
9. Racoon
10. armadillo
11. Porcupine
12. Sloth (any)
13. dik-dik
14. Spectacle Bear
15. Greater kudu
16. impala (Because I remember how funny it was watching them walk around on their hind legs in zt2)
17. Large snakes

Eh, thanks for the list but you should have read the rules

Original wishlist (random order):

1. Capybara
2. Lynx (at least one of the species)
3. Red Deer
4. Maned Wolf
5. Howler Monkey (at least one of the species)
6. Gibbon (at least one of the species)
7. White-Faced Saki
8. Spider Monkey (at least one of the species)
9. Rhea (at least one of the species) or Emu
10. Patagonian Mara
11. European Fallow Deer
12. Alpine Ibex
13. Baboon (at least one of the species)
14. Dik-Dik or Muntjac (at least one of the species)
15. Tree Kangaroo (at least one of the species)
16. Greater Kudu
17. Kobus (at least one of the species)
18. Coati (at least one of the species)
19. Sloth (at least one of the species)
20. Badger (at least one of the species)


My five additional animals:

21. Tasmanian Devil
22. Crested Porcupine
23. Sifaka (at least one of the species)
24. Bald Uakari
25. Nine Banded Armadillo


6 replace from original list:

1. Common Genet
2. Northern Tamandua
3. Indian Grey Mongoose
4. Addax
5. Kinkajou
6. Mantled Guereza

Please quote your original list so I can verify it. I won't add add anything until you post your quote.

If this still applies, with the addition of the Amur leopard and the scimitar-horned oryx I have two new slots opening up. But what to choose?

Another monkey of course! And also...
31. Golden lion tamarin.
32. Bennett's wallaby.

I do wish I could change others now, but of course I understand the complexities of the rule and the work @random goat puts in. For example, I first picked the white-cheeked gibbon on my initial list, but even at the time I would have preferred the siamang (I just went with what I felt was more likely). So really, I'm happy with our siamang and no longer want the white-cheeked gibbon on my list. Similarly, the Iberian lynx is no longer important to me. Oh well!

Yeah I get you man. I'm sorry but you original selections will stand as I can't just allow people re-voting when/if they just change their mind about their original votes.

Now that the new DLC has been announced, I feel like it's a good time for me to share my essential habitat wishlist species.

1. West Indian manatee
2. Gaur
3. Lar gibbon
4. Markhor
5. Sichuan takin
6. Fishing cat
7. American black bear
8. Emu
9. Golden snub-nosed monkey
10. Pallas' cat
11. Sand cat
12. Maned wolf
13. Caracal
14. Ocelot
15. Cape porcupine
16. Mantled guereza
17. Rock hyrax
18. Tufted gray langur
19. Serval
20. Vervet monkey
21. Red river hog
22. White-nosed coati
23. Tasmanian devil
24. African spurred tortoise
25. Shoebill

You have already submitted a list, quite a while ago. You can add 5 additional animals if you wish, as well as re-submit votes for already-in-game animals. Please read the whole Opening Post before you do so; you have to quote your original list in order to re-submit votes.

1. Tasmanian Devil
2. Bennett's Wallaby
3. Yellow-Footed Rock Wallaby
4. Emu
5. Southern Hairy-nosed Wombat
6. North Island brown kiwi.
7. Fossa
8. Iberian Lynx (would remove now we have Eurasian lynx but understand that would make things too difficult)
9. European Badger (now in game)
10. Cougar (now in game)
11. Californian Sea Lion (now in game)
12. South American Coati
13. Serval
14. Vicuna
15. Aye-aye
16. Hamadryas Baboon
17. Scimitar-horned Oryx (now in game)
18. Przewalski's Horse (now in game)
19. Small-clawed otter (now in game)
20. Old-world monkey (any)
21. Tree kangaroo (any)
22. Echidna (any)
23. Platypus (now in game)
24. Lyre bird
25. Quoll (any)

The oryx, horse, otter and platypus are all new since my last update, so 4 new ones…. I’ve already got heaps of Oceanian species on my list and most specific requests are already there, so I’m going to choose generic animals that I think fit niches that need filling:

26. Any water bird (duck, swan, goose etc.)
27. Any non rattite ground bird
28. Any new-world monkey
29. Grey langur

Please quote your original list so I can verify it. I won't add add anything until you post your quote.

1. Sulawesi Black Crested Macaque
2. Cape Porcupine
3. Black-Capped Capuchin

Please quote your original list so I can verify it. I won't add add anything until you post your quote.

This DLC gives me two slots, with the scimitar oryx and leopard, so I'm adding the Pelican and Armadillo
In summation, here is my list in it's current state:

1. Capybara Collared peccary
2. Scimitar horned Oryx Pelican (any)
3. Hamadrayas Baboon
4. Alligator Snapping turtle
5. Nile Crocodile
6. Greater Rhea
7. Grey crowned Crane
8. American Alligator Rock hyrax
9. Black Crseted Macaque
10. Yellow throated marten
11. Dromedary
12. ~Persian Fallow Deer
13. Asian small clawed otter Tree kangaroo (any)
14. Lar Gibbon
15. Emu
16. Wallaby (any)
17. Kiwi
18. Persian Leopard Armadillo (any)
19. ~Nubian Ibex
20. Aye Aye
21. Arabian Oryx
22. Two-toed sloth
23. Striped Hyena
24. Honey badger
25. Wild boar

Nope sorry yoav, the Persian leopard stays in the list as a subspecies of an already in-game species (similar to Sumatran tiger, etc.). Please choose between Pelican or Armadillo.

1. Hamadryas Baboon
2. Sea Otter
3. Bennet's Wallaby
4. Matschie's Tree Kangaroo
5. Brown-Throated Three Toed Sloth
6. Grey Crowned Crane
7. African Crested Porcupine
8. Greater Kudu
9. Sand Cat
9. Coquerel's Sifaka
10. Wolverine
11. Dromedary Camel
12. African Leopard
13. Japanese Serow
14. North American Porcupine
15. Musk Ox
16. Caracal
17. Gerenuk
18. Honey Badger
19. Secretary Bird
20. Walrus
21. Rockhopper Penguin
22. Gaur (or Asian Kouprey, if that's not considered to be extinct)
23. Saiga Antelope
24. Bat-Eared Fox
25. Jaguarundi

Siamang
Przewalski's Wild Horse

Please quote your original list so I can verify it. I won't add add anything until you post your quote.

Found back my original comment with my lost account, so by honesty I will just update this one.
8 are checked and the bonus 5 then 13 new animals to the list:
1.Pine marten
2.West Indian Manatee
3.Markhor
4.Fossa
5.GoodFellow tree kangourou
6.Pallas cat
7.Patagonian mara
8.Maned wolf
9.Red fox
10.Dromedary
11.Nile crocodile
12.Australian Pelican
13.Tasmanian devil

You realize I just can't do that? Tell me, how would I know you're the same person? If you're so willing to re-submit votes, please use your past account.

Looks like I've got 1 or 2 this time depending on how you count the leopard.

1. Golden pheasant: This game is severely lacking in birds, a group of animals that dominate zoo collections. The truth is, we don't even need an aviary expansion to address some of these birds; of which many aren't even ratites. Although the game still needs that expansion badly.
2. Grey-crowned crane: Same reasons.

I'll be replacing the oryx with the pheasant and if I'm allowed, I'll be replacing the leopard with the crane. The priority is on the pheasant, if I'm allowed only one change.

Sorry but your leopard vote went for the African leopard so it will stay on the list. I'll only add the Golden pheasant then and not the crane.

Rewrote my list to fit with the DLCs of year 3.

1. Dromedary
2. Collared Peccary
3. Brown-Throated "Three-Toed" Sloth
4. Great White Pelican
5. "African" Crested Porcupine
6. Nine-Banded Armadillo
7. Hamadryas Baboon
8. Takin
9. Fossa
10. Maned Wolf
11. "Eastern" Wild Turkey
12. Red River Hog
13. Wolverine
14. Emu
15. Tasmanian Devil
16. Striped Hyena
17. Secretary-bird
18. Common Wombat
19. Spectacled Bear
20. Walrus
21. Green Sea Turtle
22. "Common" Bottlenose Dolphin
23. West Indian Manatee
24. Blacktip Reef Shark
25. Cownose Ray

As you've been told, please highlight what are your new additions just like most people did. That would make things much easier for me and it will only take you a few seconds.

Aight, time to update this now that we can do so. Replacement species are in bold (the ones that need to be counted).

1. Addax - Even with the Scimitar-Horned Oryx, the desert biome and North Africa still need more representation. Also, I loved pairing the oryx and addax in the same enclosures in Zoo Tycoon 2 and wanna be able to do that again here.
2. African Crested Porcupine - I'm basically just joining the bandwagon here. More rodents are always appreciated.
3. Bennett's Wallaby -
4. Common Wombat - Literally just need more Australian animals. I would not mind the Southern Hairy-Nosed, but I kinda want this one more now that I've actually voted for it and want to be able to replace it when we do get a wombat (I brought this upon myself ,:').
5. Emu - THE single most necessary animal for inclusion in my eyes. It feels so wrong that we've gotten this far without it.
6. Fossa - Now that we have three lemur species in the roster, I think it's about time their apex predator gets added. One of the most unique carnivores appearance-wise.
7. Geoffroy's Spider Monkey - More new world monkeys. 'Nuff said.
8. Golden Lion Tamarin - More new world monkeys, but this time they're tini.
9. Goodfellow's Tree-Kangaroo - Probably one of the biggest animals to not make the first list. I prefer Goodfellow's as that's what Oceanian zoos tend to have (I'm gonna be so screwed if we get Matschie's tho).
10. Hamadryas Baboon - Probably the last old world monkey I really need, but I would definitely kill to get some other ones after. More desert and North African animals should be of high priority tbh.
11. Japanese Raccoon Dog - Lil pupper. One of the more unique canines not in the game yet, and adds to the ever-increasing number of East Asian animals.
12. Lar Gibbon - Not allowed to get rid of this guy even with the Siamang being added. Not that I was going to remove it anyway cus I honestly want two gibbons in the game.
13. Linnaeus's Two-Toed Sloth - Honestly, three-toed sloths are one of the few mammals to actively creep me out, something about their face feels off to me. I still want a sloth though so this is my pick, even if I'd be okay with a three-toed.
14. Little Blue Penguin - I want a penguin I can use for Australian-based zoos. Little guy is so distinct from the other two we have it shouldn't be a problem.
15. Maned Wolf - Second highest ranking animal on the list as of this post. South America still needs far more diversity and this is probably one of the most distinctive canines Frontier could add right now.
16. Muskox - A caprid that represents the arctic FAR better than the Dall Sheep does.
17. Red River Hog - Quite surprised this wasn't added in the wetlands pack considering it's a very popular option and it literally has RIVER in it's name.
18. Rock Hyrax - Probably the most out of left field of the new choices, I just really like these little guys. They're definitely a viable option size-wise as they're bigger than the meerkats.
19. Saiga Antelope - I'm surprised this animal broke the top 40 animals. Despite not really being in captivity in recent years this animal is too unique appearance-wise and biome-wise to ignore. Give us all the funni schnozz animals.
20. Secretary Bird - More birds. Can never have enough birds.
21. South American Coati - South America needs more animals and coatis are just perfect imo.
22. Takin - Takins are starting to feel like the binturong for me (except nowhere near as cool as binturongs are my favourite animal of all time). I'm talking in the sense of the species is very well known to the general public but there's so many in zoos at this stage it just makes sense to include them for the diehard zoo fans. Also more goats are always appreciated (The first animal on my mind to replace the next added animal is also a goat that is very dear to me, just you wait).
23. Tasmanian Devil - It's exlusion from the Conservation Pack raises some eyebrows in my mind considering it's now the number one most voted animal on the wishlist. I predict it'll headline one of the next two dlcs this year.
24. Walrus - The biggest pinniped currently in captivity. We need more tundra animals, and it honestly the Arctic just needs to be filled up better (the Arctic Pack really shouldn't have been the first dlc if that was how it was gonna be handled tbh).
25. Wolverine - We had THREE packs that could've included these lil rascals. What's going on here? Does Frontier just have something against wolverines? I just don't get it.

We're slowly starting to edge out of the territory of "animals that I want but also think should just be in the game for practical reasons" to "I just want this animal because it's cool". Hopefully the next two packs allow me to expand that category further (species currently on my mind but didn't make this list proper are Himalayan Tahr, Cotton-Top Tamarin and the Short-Beaked Echidna).

Edit: Gave explanations for each species again (didn't do it at the start cus it's very time consuming).

Oh boy, this one got 3 of my list, and even one of the exhibit animals I'll have to revisit in the corresponding thread. I had already addressed the capybara in a previous post (swapped it for the red fox). Not gonna attempt to remove the gibbon tho; I really want a lar.

Anyway:

27. Gerenuk
28. Patagonian mara
29. Banded mongoose

Should I edit the original post with the animals that made in crossed out and the remplacement next to them instead?

This applies to both posts above: I am sorry, but unfortunately I cannot accept your changes. I know that you most likely acted in good faith and you did nothing wrong by editing your original post was a mistake because now I have no way to check whether you made changes to your original list or not. I know you might find this 'unfair' but I ask you to put yourselves in my position. I can't just accept people to resubmit votes if I can't check whether they 'have the right' to do so.

 

[yoav_r]

Alright addressing some stuff while I get everything sorted:

Please quote your original list so I can verify it. I won't add add anything until you post your quote.

Yeah sorry Iberian ibex stands. I swapped the black rhino though.

Eh, thanks for the list but you should have read the rules

Please quote your original list so I can verify it. I won't add add anything until you post your quote.

Yeah I get you man. I'm sorry but you original selections will stand as I can't just allow people re-voting when/if they just change their mind about their original votes.

Please quote your original list so I can verify it. I won't add add anything until you post your quote.

Please quote your original list so I can verify it. I won't add add anything until you post your quote.

Please quote your original list so I can verify it. I won't add add anything until you post your quote.

Nope sorry yoav, the Persian leopard stays in the list as a subspecies of an already in-game species (similar to Sumatran tiger, etc.). Please choose between Pelican or Armadillo.

Please quote your original list so I can verify it. I won't add add anything until you post your quote.

You realize I just can't do that? Tell me, how would I know you're the same person? If you're so willing to re-submit votes, please use your past account.

Sorry but your leopard vote went for the African leopard so it will stay on the list. I'll only add the Golden pheasant then and not the crane.

As you've been told, please highlight what are your new additions just like most people did. That would make things much easier for me and it will only take you a few seconds.


This applies to both posts above: I am sorry, but unfortunately I cannot accept your changes. I know that you most likely acted in good faith and you did nothing wrong by editing your original post was a mistake because now I have no way to check whether you made changes to your original list or not. I know you might find this 'unfair' but I ask you to put yourselves in my position. I can't just accept people to resubmit votes if I can't check whether they 'have the right' to do so.

In that case I choose armadillo

 

[raf8655]

My 20 essential habitat animals that are missing (not in order of importance), also based on the many zoos visited in real life:

1. Capybara
2. Lynx (at least one of the species)
3. Red Deer
4. Maned Wolf
5. Howler Monkey (at least one of the species)
6. Gibbon (at least one of the species)
7. White-Faced Saki
8. Spider Monkey (at least one of the species)
9. Rhea (at least one of the species) or Emu
10. Patagonian Mara
11. European Fallow Deer
12. Alpine Ibex
13. Baboon (at least one of the species)
14. Dik-Dik or Muntjac (at least one of the species)
15. Tree Kangaroo (at least one of the species)
16. Greater Kudu
17. Kobus (at least one of the species)
18. Coati (at least one of the species)
19. Sloth (at least one of the species)
20. Badger (at least one of the species)

Original wishlist (random order):

1. Capybara
2. Lynx (at least one of the species)
3. Red Deer
4. Maned Wolf
5. Howler Monkey (at least one of the species)
6. Gibbon (at least one of the species)
7. White-Faced Saki
8. Spider Monkey (at least one of the species)
9. Rhea (at least one of the species) or Emu
10. Patagonian Mara
11. European Fallow Deer
12. Alpine Ibex
13. Baboon (at least one of the species)
14. Dik-Dik or Muntjac (at least one of the species)
15. Tree Kangaroo (at least one of the species)
16. Greater Kudu
17. Kobus (at least one of the species)
18. Coati (at least one of the species)
19. Sloth (at least one of the species)
20. Badger (at least one of the species)


My five additional animals:

21. Tasmanian Devil
22. Crested Porcupine
23. Sifaka (at least one of the species)
24. Bald Uakari
25. Nine Banded Armadillo


6 replace from original list:

1. Common Genet
2. Northern Tamandua
3. Indian Grey Mongoose
4. Addax
5. Kinkajou
6. Mantled Guereza

 

[ElectricMonk]

Please quote your original list so I can verify it. I won't add add anything until you post your quote.

1. Tasmanian Devil
2. Bennett's Wallaby
3. Yellow-Footed Rock Wallaby
4. Emu
5. Southern Hairy-nosed Wombat
6. North Island brown kiwi.
7. Fossa
8. Iberian Lynx
9. European Badger
10. Cougar
11. Californian Sea Lion
12. South American Coati
13. Serval
14. Vicuna
15. Aye-aye
16. Hamadryas Baboon
17. Scimitar-horned Oryx
18. Przewalski's Horse
19. Small-clawed otter
20. Old-world monkey (any)

..... Quite a few Australian animals on the list, but I still think it's the most underrepresented continent.

So, three of my initial 20 are now in game and I’d remove one since a similar species has been added.. adding 5 more is, therefore, a win. Oceania remains the least well represented region in the world so I’m just going to go ahead and add animals from there

1. Tree kangaroo (any)
2. Echidna (any)
3. Platypus
4. Lyre bird
5. Quoll (any)

 

[avietar]

@random goat

Question: I was under the impression at first that you need to list a specific species, and not a group. For instance, 'African bush elephant' instead of 'elephant'.
But what I see people do now (and understandably so, because I want to do it now too wherever I can) is to not pick a specific species but go with a group. For example 'tree kangaroo' instead of 'matschie's tree kangaroo' --to protect themselves in case the goodfellows tree kangaroo is added to the game instead. This way the vote slot opens up and they can pick a new animal. Makes perfect sense.

I just want to make sure: Is this ok?

 

[Erior]

@random goat

So, what should I do? I edited the original post striking through the animals that were added, but, its quotation in my recent post was unedited. I may also link to my update when the Wetlands pack dropped, which had a quotation of unedited text.


EDIT:

Here, https://forums.frontier.co.uk/threa...als-meta-wishlist.582340/page-91#post-9797112

As you can see, the unedited post from March 31st has in its quotation the unaltered list, hasn't been edited, and was aknowledged for usage in this list.

 

[Sammyboy159]

Here’s my list
1. Przewalski's horse
2. Eurasian Lynx
3. Capybara
4. Lar Gibbon
5. Leopard
6. Macaroni Penguin
7. Tasmanian Devil
8. Pelican
9. Wombat
10. Numbat
11. Tree Kangaroo
12. Sloth
13. Scimitar Oryx
14. Coati
15. Alpine Ibex
16. Markhor
17. Wolverine
18. Walrus
19. African Porcupine
20. Maned Wolf

Additional 11 animals to add to my list
6 from the original listdded via dlc:
Przewalski's
Eurasian Lynx
Capybara
Leopard
Scimitar Oryx
Alpine Ibex

+my 5 additional animals to make 25.
So my 11 new additions are:
1. Gerenuk
2.Golden snub nose monkey
3.Spectacled bear
4.Rock Wallaby
5.Saiga Antelope
6.Foosa
7.Spoonbill
8.Marine Iguana
9.Emu
10.Agouti
11. Secretary Bird

 

[microraptor]

1. North Island brown kiwi
2. South Island takahē
3. Golden pheasant
4. Silver pheasant
5. Lady Amherst's pheasant
6. Reeves's pheasant
7. Blue eared pheasant
8. Swinhoe's pheasant
9. Edwards's pheasant
10. Common pheasant
11. Himalayan monal
12. Satyr tragopan
13. Temminck's tragopan
14. Helmeted guineafowl
15. Any wallaby
16. Any tree kangaroo
17. Any coati
18. Any tamandua
19. Any two-toed sloth
20. Any agouti
21. Any skunk
22. Any echidna
23. Any tahr
24. Any wombat
25. Any baboon

 

[SanRazo618]

1. North Island brown kiwi
2. South Island takahē
3. Golden pheasant
4. Silver pheasant
5. Lady Amherst's pheasant
6. Reeves's pheasant
7. Blue eared pheasant
8. Swinhoe's pheasant
9. Edwards's pheasant
10. Common pheasant
11. Himalayan monal
12. Satyr tragopan
13. Temminck's tragopan
14. Helmeted guineafowl
15. Any wallaby
16. Any tree kangaroo
17. Any coati
18. Any tamandua
19. Any two-toed sloth
20. Any agouti
21. Any skunk
22. Any echidna
23. Any tahr
24. Any wombat
25. Any baboon

View attachment 310860

View attachment 310861

View attachment 310862

View attachment 310863

View attachment 310864

View attachment 310865

View attachment 310866

View attachment 310867

View attachment 310868

View attachment 310869

Birds of southeast Oceania pack

 

[Robongio]

Yes, it makes things easier for Random Goat that way. If you had voted for a generic Gibbon, I suspect you would have been able to revote that Slot, but yours is specifically Lar.

Edit: Now reading up on Random Goat's announcement, I can confirm what I just said about generic votes.

OK then! Here is the actual new one:

1. Dromedary
2. Collared Peccary
3. Brown-Throated "Three-Toed" Sloth
4. Great White Pelican
5. "African" Crested Porcupine
6. Nine-Banded Armadillo
7. Takin
8. Hamadryas Baboon
9. "Eastern" Wild Turkey
10. Lar Gibbon
11. Fossa
12. Maned Wolf
13. Red River Hog
14. Wolverine
15. Emu
16. Tasmanian Devil
17. Striped Hyena
18. Secretary-bird
19. Spectacled Bear
20. Sea Otter
21. Green Sea Turtle
22. "Common" Bottlenose Dolphin
23. West Indian Manatee
24. Blacktip Reef Shark
25. Cownose Ray

 

[random goat]

6. Mantled Guereza

Please next time I would appreciate if you specified/highlighted ONLY the animals that you're adding this specific time (just Mantled Guereza in this case). At first it would seem as if you were asking to add/replace all the others too, which has been done before. Thanks regardless.

@random goat

Question: I was under the impression at first that you need to list a specific species, and not a group. For instance, 'African bush elephant' instead of 'elephant'.
But what I see people do now (and understandably so, because I want to do it now too wherever I can) is to not pick a specific species but go with a group. For example 'tree kangaroo' instead of 'matschie's tree kangaroo' --to protect themselves in case the goodfellows tree kangaroo is added to the game instead. This way the vote slot opens up and they can pick a new animal. Makes perfect sense.

I just want to make sure: Is this ok?

You are right, and while it is definetely not ideal, it is fine. The system in place, while encourages to choose specific species, allows for more broad, generic choices. At first this was implemented for people who might not be that sharp or knowledgeable of taxonomy or specific species, but now I see people are just taking advantage of the system
Well, as I said, it's fine by me anyway.

@random goat

So, what should I do? I edited the original post striking through the animals that were added, but, its quotation in my recent post was unedited. I may also link to my update when the Wetlands pack dropped, which had a quotation of unedited text.


EDIT:

Here, https://forums.frontier.co.uk/threa...als-meta-wishlist.582340/page-91#post-9797112

View attachment 310816



As you can see, the unedited post from March 31st has in its quotation the unaltered list, hasn't been edited, and was aknowledged for usage in this list.

And I thank you very much for sharing this as evidence. Your new votes will now be valid. However, I fail to see the three animals you want to replace. Did you count the '(African) leopard'? If that's the case, that vote can't be replaced as the African leopard subspecies will stay in the list.
So you can only replace the horse and Scimi oryx. Please, choose two between:
27. Gerenuk
28. Patagonian mara
29. Banded mongoose

 

[random goat]

[removed double post]

 

[Doran]

12. Amur Leopard

Im gonna pick something stupid without single vote: bawean deer

 

[crg_41]

Here is mine:
1) Gaur
2) Nilgai
3) Takin (any subspecies)
4) Przewalski wild horse
5) European bison
6) Leopard (better if an Asian subspecies: Amur, Javan or Sri Lanka, but I want a leopard)
7) Eurasian lynx
8) Fossa
9) Capybara
10) Lar gibbon (or any othe gibbon or even the siamang)
11) Moose
12) Cougar
13) Common eland
14) Grevy zebra
15) Wolverine
16) Sea lion (any species)
17) Bennet's wallaby
18) Gelada (or any other baboon)
19) Guereza colobus
20) Walrus

My new additions (the 5 extra + the 5 for the DLCs) would be:
1) Tasmanian devil
2) Black howler monkey
3) Honey badger
4) Greater kudu
5) Red river hog
6) Markhor
7) Tree kangaroo
8) Crested pourcupine
9) Coati
10) Maned wolf

After the conservation pack I can add two more species in replacement of the wild horse and leopard (I don't know if, as I said any gibbon even the siamang that counts, but I still want the lar gibbon so I'll keep it)

1) Lowland anoa
2) Red deer

 

[random goat]

List updated you all!

I'm happy to announce that up to this date 466 people have submitted a wishlist here. Thank you all for participating!

 

[Fabian]

Yay, another chance to come up with a wishlist of animals

1. Capybara
2. Matschie’s Tree Kangaroo
3. Eurasian Lynx
4. Saiga Antelope
5. Red Deer
6. Alpine Ibex
7. Przewalski’s Horse
8. Crested Porcupine
9. American Beaver
10. Great White Pelican
11. Moose
12. European Badger
13. Arctic Fox
14. Serval
15. Fossa
16. Secretary Bird
17. Tasmanian Devil
18. Black-Tailed Prairie Dog
19. Persian Onager
20. Red Forest Duiker

Well, I don't want to brag, but counting the Fallow Deer instead of the Red Deer, I got eight animals from my wishlist out of the last two packs.

I would like to add to my wishlist the following five animals:

1. Patagonian Mara
2. South American Coati
3. Mantled Guereza
4. Walrus
5. Red River Hog

The ones who almost made the cut were the caracal, the blackbuck, the lar gibbon and the maned wolf, but I had to draw the line unfortunately. I do want to say, though, that I really want more primates in the game, even if my list doesn't really represent that wish.



And finally, thank you so much @random goat for maintaining and so regularly updating this awesome list! Checking the developments on this thread is one of my favorite parts of the PZ community, and you're doing such an awesome job here.

Guess I have eight new picks to add then!

1. Takin
2. Blackbuck
3. Nilgai
4. Lar Gibbon
5. Kinkajou
6. Black Howler Monkey
7. North Island Brown Kiwi
8. Saddle-Billed Stork

(Almost made the cut: Emu, Maned Wolf, Caracal, Wombat, Golden Lion Tamarin)

I can cross out the Przewalski's Horse from my original list, so I will now replace it with the

Golden Lion Tamarin​

To make the list more readable for myself (and for future reference), the spoiler includes an updated list of what's currently on my personal wishlist.

Spoiler

1. Matschie’s Tree Kangaroo
2. Saiga Antelope
3. Red Deer
4. Crested Porcupine
5. Great White Pelican
6. Serval
7. Fossa
8. Secretary Bird
9. Tasmanian Devil
10. Persian Onager
11. Red Forest Duiker
12. Patagonian Mara
13. South American Coati
14. Mantled Guereza
15. Walrus
16. Red River Hog
17. Takin
18. Blackbuck
19. Nilgai
20. Lar Gibbon
21. Kinkajou
22. Black Howler Monkey
23. North Island Brown Kiwi
24. Saddle-Billed Stork
25. Golden Lion Tamarin

(I still mostly stand by my choices, although my want for the Red Deer and the Lar Gibbon has been somewhat satisfied, and I would probably include the Shoebill instead of the Saddle-Billed Stork now, but would probably be happy with any stork.)

Thank you @random goat for all the hard work you put into this list, so very appreciated!

 

[Pentoleaf]

Five more:
1. Himalayan monal
2. Muscovy duck
3. Black swan
4. Scimitar horned oryx
5. Racoon

None of my + 5 Have been added, but a few have been checked off the original:

1. Red river hog
2. Pallas cat
3. Cougar Golden Pheasant
4. Bennett's wallaby
5. North american beaver Lar Gibbon
6. Dalmation pelican
7. Whooping crane
8. Helmeted Guinea fowl
9. Blackfooted ferret
10. Grey crowned crane
11. Emu
12. Saiga antelope
13. Elk / Wapiti
14. Prezwalski's wild horse
15. Iberian lynx
16. Nine-banded armidillo
17. Common squirrel monkey
18. Patagonian mara
19. Southern hairy nosed wombat
20. Capybara Japanese Serrow

1. Red river hog
2. Pallas cat
3. Golden Pheasant
4. Bennett's wallaby
5. Lar Gibbon
6. Dalmation pelican
7. Whooping crane
8. Helmeted Guinea fowl
9. Blackfooted ferret
10. Grey crowned crane
11. Emu
12. Saiga antelope
13. Elk / Wapiti
14. Prezwalski's wild horse Giant Asian pond turtle
15. Iberian lynx
16. Nine-banded armidillo
17. Common squirrel monkey
18. Patagonian mara
19. Southern hairy nosed wombat
20. Japanese Serrow
21. Himalayan monal
22. Muscovy duck
23. Black swan
24. Scimitar horned oryx - Rock hyrax
25. Racoon

Swapped out the P. horse and the oryx for Giant Asian pond turtle and rock hyrax. Thank you Randomgoat for maintaining this list (and for letting us update our votes!)

 

[SanRazo618]

Shout out to the TassieDevil and Maned Wolf! Hopefully we’ll get these oddballs soon!