That's a rare success example. If noone said anything we'd have squadron only with 100 million a week in upkeep and all the other punishments they originally configured.
Please don't consider the lowest effort they've ever put in the game.. the system map fleet carrier layout arrangements.. as proof of failure of the feature.
Also who's complaining? I use a rule of thumb when bumping into negative feedback: does it have basis, or is the person just projecting a narrow minded or anally retentive view? Any feedback positive or negative without support of reasoning should be easily ignored (if disagreeable

)