The point is there is a group of PvPers who state that the BGS and other activities should be open only. Powerplay, community goals, etc. Anything where anything can be competitive should be open only, because in their minds the only real competition is via PvP. PvE competition isn't real competition and somehow not right or cheating. They complain about how people can work the BGS (or powerplay, or do CGs) from the safety of PG/solo, because it means they can't pew-pew them to "win".
So, if FD said, here you go, your own separate open only server, your own BGS, your own powerplay, your own CGs, go to it!
And they should be happy right? Right?
Mainly i'd just love FD to do it and wait for the caterwauling how hardly anyone plays on this server and open is empty and no point doing anything and nobody to shoot.