Yeah @Rat Catcher I agree , but you also know me by now

.
Yeah, I do a bit...
Sad that we will never have our paths cross in game, I'm still uncertain if I would try to KOS or invite you to join our band of social undesirables, maybe even both!
I choose not to buy into this as I believe it is the best course of action for both myself and the group.
Utilitarianism was an interesting concept as a philosophy, but failed for a multitude of good reasons.
I have no doubt that your stance is the best course of action for yourself, solely as it is your own.
But... "for the group"?
Every player of every game is an individual, and it would be very demeaning to intimate that those individuals were unable to decide for themselves in any action they take - although your spirit of camraderie that your actions are protecting that group from themselves is commendable, probably.
In a (technically) MMO, there are thousands of players playing for themselves, even when part of an organised group, it is that mass of players who will decide, individually, what they consider to be the best course of action, they don't actually need protecting, do they?