Some really interesting setups and discussions here. I've only read a few entries but I think there is some good advice and information to take from this thread.
I just picked up a Saitek Cyborg F.L.Y 5 after having popped into PC World after work. They didn't have much (not really surprising) and I've enjoyed Cyborg hardware in the past. The stick looks great, like my old Graphite/Carbon model and it's all adjustable to suit your dimensions and reach with a dual throttle stick in addition. I must say and admit though, this joystick is a lot flimsier than I expected which could put a lot of people off. At £50, I suppose there has to be an element of quality scaling considering the more expensive HOTAS sticks need to stand above the rest. Handling the stick in-game though, it does not feel flimsy.
The action is nice and smooth although the base-buttons could be placed better (although the fact the whole thing dismantles and folds up is another negative point in terms of compromise). Personally, I can't complain. My mindset is that you shouldn't be throwing the stick around if you know what you are doing... smooth, precise adjustments should see your target off rather than reacting too late and tearing the stick from the base. I haven't played a flight/space sim in a long time though so it is taking me a while to get back into the feel of things as well as setting everything up 'just so'.
TBH, the Cyborg FLY 5 looks better than it actually is. If I played more seriously, I'd be disappointed with my purchase. But like I said, I can't complain, I might have been able to buy a better stick with the same amount of money but the FLY 5 isn't totally crap either. Tbh, anything would've done and the rest is fine tuning the controls from the options menu IMO. Others might have 'higher standards' than me but I just wanted to enjoy Elite Dangerous without having to use a keyboard/mouse or a console controller.
Anyone else with a Cyborg FLY 5, hit me up... tell me what if you agree with me or not.
Happy flying xD
NB_ I also have a Logitech G13 Gameboard which I used on/off for MMORPGs. It has a load of buttons and a joystick/hat, very useful for games with lots and lots of buttons to assign to. When I get more into the ELITE Dangerous and discover my own 'method' of what commands and controls I use most, I may use the gameboard in tandem with the joystick. Maybe it would be nice to keep flight/combat controls totally separate from everything else rather than have duel function! I don't know yet.